Games Lists

10 Character Additions That Hurt The Show (And 10 That Saved It)

10 Character Additions That Hurt The Show (And 10 That Saved It)

Brooklyn 9-9 is again with a vengeance. Fox tried to cancel it and, inside 24 hours, NBC had picked it up for an additional season. Now, we’ll get to see the tales of Jake, Amy, Terry, Captain Holt, and everybody else proceed for the foreseeable future.

Everyone knows and love the present’s essential characters: the goofy, but competent detective Jake; the dorky, straight-laced Amy; the yogurt-loving household man Terry; the fierce badass Rosa; the bizarre, food-obsessed Charles; the wrong duo of Hitchcock and Scully; the strict, deadpan Captain Holt; and his sarcastic, social media savvy assistant Gina. However the present’s forged of characters goes a lot deeper and wider than that. There are different cops, a few of whom even work totally different shifts in the identical precinct, and the primary forged’s household and buddies from their lives outdoors work, and love pursuits, and one-off visitor roles. The listing is countless. As with all TV present, a few of these character additions have labored and develop into simply as beloved as the primary forged, however most of the time, the characters have fallen flat and needed to be written out.

We’ve been launched to dozens of latest characters throughout greater than 100 episodes of Brooklyn 9-9. So, with out additional ado, listed here are 10 Character Additions That Hurt The Show (And 10 That Saved It).

Proceed scrolling to maintain studying

Click on the button under to start out this text in fast view

Begin Now

20 Hurt – Darlene Linetti

Sandra Bernhard’s flip as Gina’s mom Darlene Linetti left lots to be desired. She’s egocentric, annoying, and she or he wasn’t variety to Boyle’s pretty dad. It was just like the writers took all of the worst qualities of Gina and disregarded the redeeming elements.

As arduous as it might be to consider, Gina is definitely one of many present’s least widespread characters. She will get a whole lot of love on social media, as a result of she is an correct reflection of the social media customers who’re writing these posts. However different viewers have posted on Reddit that Gina is their least favourite character due to her vanity. The distinction between Gina and Darlene, nevertheless, is that Gina is an effective individual at coronary heart. Darlene isn’t.

19 Saved – Teddy Wells

Teddy just isn’t a likable character, however his infatuation with Amy by no means fails to get amusing. He’s been used simply the correct quantity – he’s all the time humorous and it by no means feels previous. Teddy started because the wedge between Jake and Amy, however now that they’re fortunately collectively, he’s simply the weirdo on the sidelines who nonetheless thinks there’s a love triangle even if one in every of them has clearly gained Amy’s coronary heart.

Whether or not it’s proposing to her in entrance of Jake or hurting her professionally to get a date out of her, his obsession with Amy paired together with her willpower to not lead him on in any approach make Teddy a welcome addition to the present.

18 Hurt – Victor Santiago

Whereas Jimmy Smits does a very good job of enjoying Amy’s father as a robust affect on her, with the identical look after group and police work as her, he’s not a comedy man. He’s partaking when he performs dramatic roles in exhibits like L.A. Regulation, The West Wing, and Dexter, however he’s not humorous. His character isn’t even written as humorous.

The father who disapproves of his daughter’s life decisions is a personality that has been written into each sitcom for many years. There’s nothing unique concerning the father whose youngster all the time fails to impress him, and so there’s nothing recent or fascinating about this character in Brooklyn 9-9.

17 Saved – Lynn Boyle

Stephen Root is nice in every part, so in fact he makes the record. He’s finished each comedy (Workplace Area, Dodgeball, The Males Who Stare at Goats) and drama (No Nation for Previous Males, Get Out) brilliantly. Additionally, he performs Boyle’s father so nicely as an much more exaggerated model of Boyle himself.

Very similar to John Lithgow did when he performed Will Ferrell’s dad in Daddy’s House 2, Root takes all the traits that the actor imbues into his character’s son – on this case, the female conduct and vocal inflections of Joe Lo Truglio – and exaggerates them so the viewers can see the place the son obtained them from. It’s fairly masterful, and all the time very humorous.

16 Hurt – Jack Hazard

It was a terrific concept to have a personality with the identify Jack Hazard be the lamest, blandest, most boring character ever created. Plus, Ed Helms is often nice – particularly in The Workplace, certainly one of Michael Schur’s different TV comedies. However the Jack Hazard joke wore skinny in a short time and, whereas he started the episode as boring in a humorous approach, he had simply turn into genuinely boring by the top.

The episode “USPIS” during which the character seems just isn’t a weak episode of the collection, however the visitor character that it revolves round is weak. Andy Samberg manages to hold the scenes with Jack Hazard in them, however it’s only a disgrace. Helms deserves higher.

15 Saved – Cagney and Lacey Jeffords

It’s essential that Brooklyn 9-9’s least masculine character (besides perhaps Charles) is performed by Terry Crews. It says rather a lot about gender roles. Terry loves yogurt and he’s probably the most scared one within the precinct when Jake brings in a tarantula – however most significantly, he’s a loving father. By bringing Cagney and Lacey into the present and having Terry commit as a dad or mum, the present gave audiences a very constructive male position mannequin.

The arrival of Terry’s daughters is what made him lose his nerve. He couldn’t exit within the area as a fearless cop anymore, as a result of he couldn’t stand the considered not attending to see his daughters develop up. It’s so heartfelt and candy and relatable. It makes Terry much more lovable – if that was even attainable.

14 Hurt – Roger Peralta

Jake’s father who deserted him in all probability ought to’ve remained unseen like Howard Wolowitz’s equally absent father in The Massive Bang Concept. He has a bunch of secret households everywhere in the nation. Though Bradley Whitford is a unbelievable actor, it’s unattainable to love Roger Peralta after what he’s executed.

Roger has achieved some type of redemption in current seasons as he and Karen have gotten again collectively and she or he insists he’s modified. The one instance of how he’s “changed” is that he introduced Karen soup when she was sick. However that’s not sufficient to undo all the key double lives and deserted youngsters and repeated infidelities.

13 Saved – Keith Pembroke (the Vulture)

Okay, the Vulture is a complete jerk – however that’s what makes him so nice. He’s solely nice in small doses, which is why the story arc during which he captained the precinct irritated so many followers. However on the entire, he works as a personality, as a result of Dean Winters is nice at enjoying the man you like to hate – he did the identical factor together with his 30 Rock character.

A part of the longevity of the Vulture character is that he has been round because the fifth episode of the present. So, he was an enormous a part of our introduction into the world of the present – that’s what the primary ten or so episodes of a collection are for.

12 Hurt – Kate Peralta

In Brooklyn 9-9’s fifth season, Andy Samberg’s SNL cohort Nasim Pedrad guest-starred as Jake’s half-sister Kate. Her erratic and typically felony conduct made her stick with Jake and Amy considerably entertaining, however she wasn’t an excellent character. The power of the episode got here from Jake and Amy’s reactions to the chaos Kate introduced into their house, however Kate herself was not a robust character.

Pedrad has all the time been a hilarious comedian expertise, whilst a visitor star in different exhibits. Her visitor position in Curb Your Enthusiasm’s most up-to-date season as yet one more sufferer of Larry David’s campaign was hysterical. And it’s a pleasant contact that she performs Andy Samberg’s sister like she did in a well-known SNL sketch. However the character was too insane for the tone of the present.

11 Saved – Genevieve Mirren-Carter

Mary Lynn Rajskub is all the time sensible – whether or not she’s enjoying the sarcastic, tech-savvy Chloe in 24 or Gail the Snail in It’s All the time Sunny in Philadelphia – and she or he was the right casting for the a part of Genevieve Mirren-Carter in Brooklyn 9-9. Genevieve is the excellent match for Charles Boyle, and she or he’s simply as humorous as him, too.

As bizarre as Boyle is, we all the time needed him to be comfortable, and the one approach for him to be glad can be to discover a lady who was as uncommon and obsessive about meals as he’s – and in Genevieve, that’s precisely what he obtained. Now, they’ve a son, Nicolaj, and a cheerful life collectively.

10 Hurt – Captain Seth Dozerman

As hilarious as Invoice Hader often is, his Brooklyn 9-9 character was an enormous disappointment. He was launched within the third season premiere as Captain Holt’s even stricter alternative, he didn’t have any humorous strains, after which he was eradicated. He was the DeAngelo Vickers of Brooklyn 9-9.

The writers ought to’ve simply began off with the Vulture as Holt’s alternative, since that was the primary story arc. It was virtually like they needed to begin the season twice – as soon as with Seth Dozerman after which once more with the Vulture. The character was annoying, unfunny, and even worse, pointless. He didn’t stay as much as Hader’s expertise, which is an issue that plenty of visitor characters in Brooklyn 9-9 have.

9 Saved – Hearth Marshal Boone

Any excuse to get Patton Oswalt right into a sitcom goes to be the appropriate transfer. He’s probably the greatest comics working in the present day and he all the time makes an impression when he seems in a comedy collection, regardless of how small the position is. This one was sweetened by the connection Boone made with Jake over their fathers abandoning them, breaking down the wall of their rivalry.

Hopefully, we’ll be seeing extra of Hearth Marshal Boone sooner or later, as a result of he’s lots of enjoyable. Perhaps he and Peralta can group up on an arson case. Together with his standup performances and starring roles in different exhibits like A.P. Bio and Completely satisfied!, Oswalt won’t have the time – but when he might squeeze it in, it will be nice.

eight Hurt – Adrian Pimento

Jason Mantzoukas is comedically fairly gifted, as proven by his roles in The League and The Dictator, however his Brooklyn 9-9 character was too intense and insane to ever be endearing. His line supply, and even the strains themselves, have been approach too over-the-top to be humorous. He can be satisfactory as a one-off visitor character, however he had a multi-episode story arc and a romantic relationship with one of many principal characters.

When Rosa suspected Pimento of sneaking round behind her again, many followers have been rejoicing, as a result of he’d lastly be gone from the present. There was a quick terror when he was revealed to have been trustworthy that he may stick round, however fortunately, Rosa caught to her weapons and dumped him anyway. Good riddance.

7 Saved – Madeline Wuntch

Kyra Sedgwick’s flip as Captain Holt’s cold-hearted rival opened his character as much as a few of his funniest moments, like when he realized her identify rhymed with “lunch” and reacted as if he’d saved the world. She works nicely as a villain, as she places all types of obstacles in entrance of Holt’s goals, so she’s good for story.

Wuntch just isn’t a lovable character like Terry or Boyle, however she is enjoyable to hate, which is what makes quite a few minor characters in Brooklyn 9-9 work: the Vulture, Teddy and so on. Her standoffs and confrontations with Holt are all the time hilarious, as a result of they every put simply as a lot panache into their line supply: zero.

6 Hurt – Marcus

Captain Holt’s nephew Marcus was a likable character and a great romantic associate for Rosa, however he simply wasn’t humorous. He’s a type of characters who audiences don’t actively dislike, however who by no means makes his mark with any robust jokes or character-driven gags. He was performed by Nick Cannon, who’s a gifted actor, however the issue was within the character’s writing.

He was an excellent man who all the time handled Rosa proper and didn’t exhibit any destructive stereotypes in his characterization, which is fairly necessary. However on the finish of the day, this can be a comedy collection, and if a personality doesn’t make viewers snigger, then they’re going to activate them fairly shortly.

5 Saved – Karen Peralta

Katey Sagal can play anybody’s mom – Penny’s, Kelly and Bud Bundy’s, the Hennessy clan’s, even Jax Teller’s – and make them a beloved TV character. She does the identical with the position of Jake Peralta’s mom, Karen, in Brooklyn 9-9. All of her line deliveries are pitch good and, as all the time, she’s extremely watchable.

Karen is characterised completely as a basic mother character, too. She loves Diane Keaton, Jane Seymour, pink wine, Jimmy Carter, and making an attempt to make amends for society’s norms. Plus, the truth that she left Jake’s dad Roger exhibits she’s a robust one that gained’t take any guff from anybody.

four Hurt – C.J.

Ken Marino’s comedic persona solely works if the stability between brash confidence and inept insecurity is good. David Wain is aware of the best way to strike this stability, which is why Marino’s roles in films like Moist Scorching American Summer time, Position Fashions, and Wanderlust work so properly. Nevertheless, the stability was off in Brooklyn 9-9 when he performed C.J., the idiotic captain who tried to cover his idiocy from his superiors.

One factor the writers of Brooklyn 9-9 are often nice at doing is creating supporting characters you like to hate to populate the world across the characters you’re keen on to like (Jake, Amy, Holt, Terry and so forth.). C.J. was clearly meant as certainly one of these characters, nevertheless it didn’t work.

three Saved – Doug Judy (the Pontiac Bandit)

The method the connection between Jake and the Pontiac Bandit has developed through the years has been actually fascinating. He started as a one-off villain, however he’s since come again a couple of occasions through the years – and his character turns into extra outlined and developed with every look. Plus, Craig Robinson is hilarious in something he’s in.

Brooklyn 9-9 marked the second time Craig Robinson labored with the present’s government producer Michael Schur, because the two beforehand labored collectively on The Workplace, which Schur was a author for. It’s potential that if it wasn’t for his or her established working relationship, Doug Judy wouldn’t make so many appearances in Brooklyn 9-9, so we have now The Workplace to thank for this character.

2 Hurt – Jess Day

New Girl Brooklyn Nine Nine Crossover

The crossover between Brooklyn 9-9 and New Woman was a nasty concept from the get-go. Shoehorning Jess Day into an episode of Brooklyn 9-9 the place she simply occurs to assist Jake Peralta clear up a case is the sort of cheesy, pressured, gimmicky TV occasion that we thought we’d grown out of within the golden age of tv.

Plus, lots of people can’t stand Zooey Deschanel’s “adorkable” on-screen persona, so you possibly can’t simply pressure it on unsuspecting viewers. In the event that they like Deschanel, they’ll watch New Woman. In the event that they don’t, they’ll watch one thing else, like Brooklyn 9-9, so it’s unfair to have her simply present up in a totally totally different collection. Even individuals who do like Deschanel and her present thought this crossover was gratuitous.

1 Saved – Kevin Cozner

Captain Holt’s husband Kevin Cozner might have begun his life on the present as a wordplay gag, however he has blossomed into one of many present’s most essential characters. Marc Evan Jackson performs Kevin with such humility and dignity – very similar to how Andre Braugher performs Holt himself – that he has turn out to be a forerunner for constructive illustration of their group within the media.

The character has all the time had a plausible, partaking relationship with Holt, however in current seasons, he’s additionally been creating an incredible rapport with Jake. The story arc by which the 2 of them needed to reside in a protected home along with nothing however Jake’s assortment of Nicolas Cage films was a spotlight.

!perform(f,b,e,v,n,t,s)
if(f.fbq)return;n=f.fbq=perform() n.callMethod?
n.callMethod.apply(n,arguments):n.queue.push(arguments);
if(!f._fbq)f._fbq=n;n.push=n;n.loaded=!zero;n.model=’2.zero’;
n.queue=[];t=b.createElement(e);t.async=!zero;
t.src=v;s=b.getElementsByTagName(e)[0];
s.parentNode.insertBefore(t,s)(window, doc,’script’,
‘https://connect.facebook.net/en_US/fbevents.js’);
fbq(‘init’, ‘297467373958238’);
fbq(‘monitor’, ‘PageView’);
if((window.location.href.indexOf(“utm_source”)!=-1))
setTimeout(perform() fbq(‘monitor’, ‘ViewContent’); , 3000);

(perform(d, s, id)
var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0];
if (d.getElementById(id)) return;
js = d.createElement(s); js.id = id;
js.src = “//connect.facebook.net/en_US/sdk.js#xfbml=1&version=v2.10”;
fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js, fjs);
(doc, ‘script’, ‘facebook-jssdk’));

(perform(d, s, id)
var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0];
if (d.getElementById(id)) return;
js = d.createElement(s); js.id = id;
js.src = “//connect.facebook.net/en_US/sdk.js#xfbml=1&version=v2.10”;
fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js, fjs);
(doc, ‘script’, ‘facebook-jssdk’));