Adonis Medina Andy MacPhail Angelo Cataldi Brett Brown Eagles Games John Middleton Jonah Bolden Kawhi Leonard Manny Machado Matt Klentak Mike Muscala MLB Trade Deadline NBA Free Agency Opinion Philadelphia Phillies Sixers Sixto Sanchez Sports

Angelo Cataldi: To win big, Phillies must be willing to risk big — and that means dealing prospects

Angelo Cataldi: To win big, Phillies must be willing to risk big — and that means dealing prospects

John Middleton was sitting proper throughout from me final yr, providing some uncommon public insights into proudly owning the Phillies, once I determined to take a calculated risk. I requested him on my WIP radio present how he felt about being referred to as the subsequent George Steinbrenner. His immediate smile shocked me.

“I love the comparison,” Middleton stated. “I would love to have as many rings as George does.”

Based mostly on the irritating developments of the previous week, I would really like to retract my query retroactively. That is no probability – zero – that the blustery late Yankee proprietor would have tolerated the timid, loser mentality of his underlings the best way Middleton simply did.

In case you missed it, the Phillies didn’t acquire the prize of this yr’s trade-deadline sweepstakes, Manny Machado, as a result of president Andy MacPhail and GM Matt Klentak have been unwilling to pay the worth. And that worth was a hard-throwing righthanded pitcher named Sixto Sanchez.

Turning 20 later this week, Sanchez is the prize of the Phillies farm system, a child who can contact 100 miles per hour on the radar gun – and isn’t that all that issues within the analytics-obsessed Phillies group nowadays?

Sanchez continues to be in A-ball, no less than three years away from incomes a promotion to Philadelphia. Would you like to know what number of youngsters like Sanchez by no means make all of it the best way to the big leagues? I’ll finish the suspense proper now. Virtually all of them. The very fact that Sanchez is putting out lower than one batter an inning in A ball, regardless of his stuff, is the primary warning signal.

However not to MacPhail and Klentak, who repeatedly reinforce their passive strategy in phrase and deed. Three years into their tenures, their credo is to wait, wait, wait,

Yeah, I do know. The Phillies are exceeding all expectations this season, 12 video games above .500 atop the NL East standings. Nobody needs to acknowledge that a lot of the fundamental individuals on this sudden rebirth have been right here earlier than MacPhail and Klentak arrived as a result of that would break the glad narrative. The reality is, MacPhail and Klentak are close to the highest of the league executives in prospect whiffs.

The most important is Mickey Moniak, the No. 1 decide in your complete draft two years in the past. Moniak continues to be caught in A ball, batting .247 within the Florida State League, with an on-base proportion of .281. Seven of the younger gamers from that draft are already ranked within the prime 100 in baseball. Moniak isn’t one among them.

Now we’re supposed to consider that the sensible baseball minds who botched the highest decide 25 months in the past have gotten it proper this time with Sixto Sanchez? No, thanks. One of the best prospect MacPhail and Klentak have been willing to supply within the Machado deal was one other pitcher, Adonis Medina, who has a four.48 earned run common pitching on the identical employees as Sanchez in Clearwater.

In the meantime, the Dodgers gained Machado by providing one of many gems of their farm system, Yusniel Diaz, who was hitting .314 in AA ball, a step above Sanchez. Why was Los Angeles willing to outbid the Phillies? Might it be as a result of they’re making an attempt to win in the present day, the best way Steinbrenner when he earned seven championship rings?

Final Friday night time, whereas Machado was main his new workforce to victory with two hits and two walks, Klentak was congratulating himself for making “a pretty strong run at it.” Yup, he stated that. The child GM needs credit score for coming pretty shut.

Are you able to think about how Steinbrenner would have reacted if his longtime GM Brian Cashman expressed satisfaction at an effort that failed?

Properly, based mostly on what occurred final week, Matt Klentak is not any Brian Cashman.

And, unhappy to say, John Middleton is certainly no George Steinbrenner.

* * *

Is there something extra annoying in sports activities proper now than this fixation athletes have on enjoying in Los Angeles? Hey, I like In-N- Out burgers as a lot as anyone, however let’s get critical right here. L. A, is a awful place for a sports activities hero to play.

First, it was LeBron James, who clearly has turned his consideration away from profitable championships and towards a second profession in Hollywood. Regardless of his bogus flirtation with the Sixers final month, it was apparent after phrase leaked that he had two movies in manufacturing that the brand new setting for his dream is three,000 miles away from Philadelphia.

Then it was Manny Machado, who might barely include his pleasure after the Dodgers outbid the Phillies in a commerce final week. Despite the fact that he’ll be a free agent after this season, the brand new considering now’s that Machado will take pleasure in enjoying in Los Angeles a lot, he gained’t need to come again to the East Coast. 

“Obviously,” he stated after his first recreation, “I love L.A.”

Lastly, a robust argument might be made that Kawhi Leonard would be a Sixer at the moment if he hadn’t knowledgeable everybody months in the past that he deliberate to signal with the Lakers when he’s a free agent after subsequent season. Finally, he was traded final week to Toronto, which he instantly dominated out as a long-term vacation spot.


RELATED: AL Morganti: Lacking on Kawhi, Machado large missteps for Philly


Do these sports activities heroes, with the expiration dates on the prime of their careers approaching, actually know what they’re getting themselves into in La-La Land? Properly, I’m right here to assist.

For starters, L.A. is a sports activities metropolis gripped by apathy, and I’m not simply speaking concerning the fame of Dodgers followers arriving within the third inning and leaving within the seventh. For those who noticed the best way Eagles followers took over the West Coast stadiums of the Chargers and Rams final season, you already understand how rather more we care right here. I used to be there. We owned that metropolis.

Additionally, the life-style of a sports activities star in Los Angeles is way extra bodily demanding than right here, each due to the hundreds of additional journey miles required to play within the much more populated East and additionally due to the a lot earlier begin occasions. Let’s see how a lot Manny Machado loves Hollywood when he’s enjoying an East-Coast recreation at 10 a.m., L.A. time.

After which there’s the ridiculous notion that these sports activities stars can commerce of their reputation for film success. When is the final time Michael Jordan starred in a movie? Shaquille O’Neal? Even Ray Allen, who truly has a little bit of appearing capability? LeBron James won’t be the subsequent Denzel Washington. He simply doesn’t comprehend it but.

Chase Utley is again on the town beginning tonight for his last bow in Philadelphia. A real sports activities hero right here, Utley went house to L.A. three years in the past and has performed in relative anonymity since then. He’ll stay there as a full-time dad after this season.

Utley has it proper. If you retire, then it’s time to contemplate the nice and cozy climate and juicy burgers of L.A. Earlier than then, it’s much better to play in a fantastic sports activities metropolis like Philadelphia, the place the individuals actually care.

* * *

Wilson Chandler, Mike Muscala, Jonah Bolden … cease me once you see the identify of an NBA star. Keep in mind, Sixers coach and interim GM Brett Brown promised followers he would go “star-hunting” when he acquired an unprotected 2021 first-round decide within the draft final month.

On the time, all of us thought Brown was speaking about Kawhi Leonard or Paul George or – dare we are saying? – LeBron James. Aside from the very fact that all of them occur to play basketball, Chandler, Muscala and Bolden don’t have anything in widespread with Leonard, George and James. They’re role-players, names on the underside of the stat sheet.

So what occurred to Brown’s formidable plan? Properly, it may need fared higher if the Sixers truly employed a basic supervisor. In any case, it has been two months now since Bryan Colangelo took his spouse’s nutty Twitter accounts and logged off. What’s taking so lengthy?

Probably the most amusing improvement on this lengthy seek for a brand new GM got here final week, when information leaked that Sixers proprietor Joshua Harris had tried to lure Daryl Morey, the chief of the yr – and mentor to exiled hero Sam Hinkie – from Houston. In fact, Morey turned Harris down. It’s a protected guess that Hinkie has already advised his previous pal about his clueless ex-boss.

Don’t misunderstand. That is no endorsement of the clumsy work of Colangelo as GM, nor a nod to Hinkie’s dropping tenure. Granted, the Sixers ended up with one real celebrity, Joel Embiid, and one other elite expertise in Ben Simmons, however anybody who believes the Sixers have the inspiration of a champion is delusional.

What the Sixers desperately want is a veteran star to lead them previous extra skilled franchises like Boston and Toronto, and they’ve accomplished nothing to date to handle that void. At this level, with Leonard becoming a member of the Raptors, the hole is wider than it was on the finish of the season, with no speedy prospect for enchancment.

In fact, Markelle Fultz might lastly rediscover his misplaced leap shot, Simmons might develop some capturing vary of his personal and Embiid might discover the elusive formulation for good well being. Perhaps Chandler, Muscata and Bolden can present some sudden assist, too.

And perhaps I’ll win a Pulitzer Prize for this column.

I simply wouldn’t guess on any of that occurring, would you?

* * *

And eventually . . .

• Does Phillies president Andy MacPhail have a authorized residence within the Delaware Valley? Has anybody ever seen him inside the metropolis limits of Philadelphia? I pose these questions as a result of he appears to make himself out there to the media annually in Clearwater at spring coaching and then once more on the street round mid-season. Final week, he spoke in Miami. The person has been operating one in every of our most necessary franchises for 3 years now. It will be good for us to see his face – and get the prospect to ask a query or two – proper right here in Philadelphia. Or is that asking an excessive amount of?

• When he did converse, what Andy MacPhail stated ought to trigger some concern within the workforce’s board room, beginning with proprietor John Middleton. MacPhail defined the Phillies’ dangerous attendance this season as a by-product of the success of the Eagles and Sixers. In different phrases, the Phils are powerless to prosper financially in Philadelphia if our different sports activities groups are robust? I want Dallas Inexperienced have been nonetheless right here to inform Andy MacPhail what he thinks of that lame concept. I can solely hope John Middleton does.

• Probably the most overpaid government in American enterprise is NFL commissioner Roger Goodell. He makes shut to $40 million a yr to make big selections about America’s hottest sport, and but he simply retains bumbling the most important points. His choice final week to droop his idiotic new anthem coverage whereas he negotiates an settlement with the gamers affiliation was the newest instance of his ineptitude. It took all this time for him to understand the gamers deserved some say on this nationwide debate? That’s superb.

• Talking of dangerous strikes by a commissioner, prime baseball boss Rob Manfred thought it was a good suggestion to criticize the sport’s greatest participant, Mike Trout, final week for not advertising himself aggressively sufficient. In contrast to so many lesser stars, Trout performs onerous on a regular basis and is unfailingly respectful to followers and media. For this he acquired ripped on the All-Star Recreation. What MLB might use proper now’s a commissioner who’s nearly as good at his job as Mike Trout. 

• Two days earlier than the Eagles open coaching camp, Texas native Jason Peters is already in midseason type when it comes to harassing Cowboys followers. Final week, the big deal with stated: “People tell me, “Y’all got lucky (by winning the Super Bowl.)’ I just say, ‘Too bad y’all haven’t been lucky in 20-something years.’” Truly, it’s now 22 years since Dallas final gained the Tremendous Bowl. Thanks, Jason Peters.