Arizona Diamondbacks Arizona Diamondbacks Stories Games Paul Goldschmidt zack greinke

Arizona Sports reviews the Paul Goldschmidt trade to the Cardinals

Arizona Sports reviews the Paul Goldschmidt trade to the Cardinals

Paul Goldschmidt traded Sedona purple for Cardinal purple.

The previous Arizona Diamondbacks first baseman was moved to the St. Louis Cardinals on Wednesday in a deal that noticed the D-backs purchase pitcher Luke Weaver, catcher Carson Kelly, infielder Andy Younger and a draft decide.

The transfer comes as common supervisor Mike Hazen’s employees considers the long-term monetary flexibility of the staff. An apparent sacrifice to that finish, Arizona loses a pacesetter and arguably the most heralded Diamondback in the workforce’s 20-plus-year historical past.

We requested present hosts, producers and reporters at 98.7 FM Arizona’s Sports Station their favourite Goldschmidt reminiscence, their preliminary response to buying and selling the first baseman and what ought to come of the subsequent bullet-point on Hazen’s to-do record: What to do with pitcher Zack Greinke.


1) What’s your prompt response to Paul Goldschmidt being traded?

Doug Franz, co-host of Doug & Wolf: It was 100 % the proper transfer to trade him. I feel it was 45 % the proper trade. Give me Dakota Hudson, the Cardinals’ second-best pitching prospect, and I’m all in. The trade as is proves the D-backs we’re able of weak spot and felt they couldn’t get any higher than what they obtained from anybody else in baseball.

They might have determined it wasn’t sufficient after which wait till the trade deadline. Then they’re handcuffed by the season he would have. Most gamers don’t do nicely when everybody is aware of they’re going to get traded. May need been an aesthetic transfer by the staff to assist Goldy keep away from a yr like that.

Vince Marotta, co-host of Bickley & Marotta: There are lots of “instant reactions” to Paul Goldschmidt being traded.

In the beginning, it’s a actuality of baseball in a market like Phoenix. The D-backs hit a house run by discovering Goldy in the eighth spherical of the 2009 draft (out of Texas State, of all locations) and creating him of their system.

We acquired to take pleasure in watching him flip into the sport’s most humble star, however the monetary windfall that’s free company and aggressive (irresponsible, perhaps) strikes by Arizona’s earlier entrance workplace made the probabilities of re-signing Goldschmidt to a fats deal unimaginable.

The considered a homegrown celebrity spending his complete profession in Sedona pink is good, nevertheless it simply doesn’t occur outdoors of main markets in baseball anymore.

Dave Burns, co-host of Burns & Gambo: Had to occur. Had to. In the event that they didn’t trade Goldy now there are two very doubtless outcomes and one very distant attainable various. The 2 doubtless outcomes are 1) attempt to trade him at the deadline however danger damage or 2) watch him stroll at the finish of subsequent season and get nothing however a comp decide for him. An excessive amount of danger and too little return for my tastes. The distant risk was resigning him however his affordability, his age and the reality the group is approaching a rebuild made that an irrational proposition. Emotionally, Wednesday was an terrible day. There was little or no in the approach of options.

John Gambadoro, co-host of Burns & Gambo: This was a transfer the D-backs didn’t need to make however one that they had to make. The truth is that they weren’t going to give you the option to maintain him and that if they’re in a rebuild, which it appears they’re, they shouldn’t have needed to hold him. Paul Goldschmidt had one yr left on his contract earlier than hitting free company at the age of 32. It might not have been clever to re-sign him at that age and for the cash he would command if they’re a number of years away from competing.

Mike Hazen did the greatest he might in dealing a participant who’s a rental for St. Louis. There are not any ensures the Cardinals might be in a position to maintain him past the 2019 season. Goldy can be clever to play out the yr and check the market. Arizona acquired again amount moreso than high quality, however the gamers they obtained again will match into the system and will help — and most significantly are beneath workforce management for a few years.

Luke Weaver pitched towards Arizona final yr going 6 1/three innings with three hits, one run and 7 strikeouts. He shall be a pleasant addition to the rotation. Carson Kelly appears to be the actual sort of catcher this group loves — defensive-minded — and with Jeff Mathis now gone, they definitely wanted catching assist.

Jordan Byrd, producer of Burns & Gambo and host of Arizona Sports Saturday: Regardless that it’s arduous to consider that he’s truly gone, I’m not stunned Paul Goldschmidt has been traded. I had already braced myself that buying and selling Goldy now was the solely factor that made sense. The fan in me will clearly miss having an MVP-caliber enjoying on the roster, however Mike Hazen simply couldn’t danger having Goldy stroll away for nothing at the finish of this subsequent yr. I do know some followers could also be upset with them, however I’m happy the entrance workplace had the guts to do one thing unpopular but pragmatic.

Matt Layman, ArizonaSports.com editor, reporter and social: It’s troublesome, nevertheless it’s comprehensible.

The Diamondbacks did one thing that might’ve been borderline silly not to do. Patrick Corbin is gone. A.J. Pollock in all probability is, too. And even with that trio on the roster, the D-backs didn’t accomplish their final aim the final two seasons. Dropping your beginning middle fielder and one in every of your greatest beginning pitchers signifies that hanging on to Paul Goldschmidt for yet one more yr and letting him stroll for nothing (or signing him to an extension at a time when the workforce is re-tooling) might’ve confirmed disastrous.

As an alternative, the D-backs get again three prospects, every with a less-than-100-percent probability of being massive leaguers, however mixed, the odds that one among them turns into a productive participant on your franchise is sort of good. And to get that for a man who might find yourself being a rental for St. Louis – as well as to getting a compensatory decide and a $14.5 million financial savings subsequent yr – isn’t dangerous.

Simply since you haven’t heard of the gamers coming again doesn’t imply the return is sub-standard.

Kevin Zimmerman, ArizonaSports.com editor and reporter: Followers can hate it. They need to. However the solely different choice was preserving Goldschmidt and banking on efficiently pulling off a fire-sale round him. In the event that they traded Zack Greinke and strong regulars from David Peralta to Robbie Ray, perhaps the D-backs would’ve discovered themselves with sufficient cash of their pockets to pay Goldschmidt.

That’s asking for lots. And that’s risking that Goldschmidt would need to return to a totally rebuilding D-backs group after the 2019 season.

It simply didn’t look potential. That they had to get one thing for him. As for the return, it doesn’t look nice on paper, however usable gamers and future belongings are included. And the Cardinals weren’t giving up prime prospects for a man they’re taking a long-term danger by buying.


2) What’s your favourite Paul Goldschmidt reminiscence?

Doug Franz, co-host of Doug & Wolf: The triple at residence to get rid of the Giants and clinch the 2011 Nationwide League West. I used to be at the recreation holding my daughter. We have been each standing yelling, “Goldy … Goldy.” The realist in me completely understands this transfer. The dad in me hates it.

Vince Marotta, co-host of Bickley & Marotta: It’s a bit egocentric and occurred off the area, nevertheless it’s once we received the famously quiet slugger to play “Vinny Joe Trivia” on the topic of Billy Madison. On the area, there’s too many to rely. Goldschmidt is the consummate skilled and shall be missed. And as a lot because it pains me to say it, he’ll slot in completely in St. Louis.

Dave Burns, co-host of Burns & Gambo: I’ll always remember how good Goldschmidt was and the way a lot he hated the consideration that got here with being good. I can’t pinpoint a selected reminiscence largely as a result of he was so persistently good from virtually the second he was referred to as up. However I’ll always remember his humility at being certainly one of the greatest in the recreation.

Jordan Byrd, producer of Burns & Gambo and host of Arizona Sports Saturday: Once I consider Paul Goldschmidt, the very first thing that comes to thoughts isn’t a selected second essentially, it’s extra a common theme. Paul Goldschmidt was the most humble and unassuming star there might ever be. In a sports activities market that has seen gamers like Larry Fitzgerald, Shane Doan and Kurt Warner, Goldy stood out together with his low-key character that allowed his play to do the majority of his speaking.

However for those who’re asking me to decide one reminiscence, I’ve to go together with Goldy hitting three residence runs whereas coping with three separate rain delays towards the Cubs final season at Wrigley Area.

Matt Layman, ArizonaSports.com editor, reporter and social: I keep in mind means again to 2011 when Paul Goldschmidt hit a grand slam in the NLDS towards Milwaukee in his rookie season. You figured then the man was going to be a stud, and he’s simply that.

Kevin Zimmerman, ArizonaSports.com editor and reporter: His is dry as a bone when it comes to giving nice quotes or soundbites, however I appreciated that he knew it. I liked listening to reporters attempt to squeeze any pleasure out of him by asking 5 questions in a row, making an attempt to get him to speak about himself. Goldschmidt would all the time give credit score to his teammates and even cracked slightly grin as he repeated himself. He knew what they have been wanting and he knew he wasn’t going to give it to them. Additionally, seeing this in individual.


three) What ought to the Diamondbacks do with Zack Greinke?

Doug Franz, co-host of Doug & Wolf: Ask him what occurred in the 2017 Wild Card recreation towards Colorado when Lovullo had to go to Ray, eliminating Robbie from pitching recreation one at Dodger Stadium.

Vince Marotta, co-host of Bickley & Marotta: As for what the D-backs ought to do with Zack Greinke, that reply is now clear.

With the dreaded “rebuild” firmly in place, it is unnecessary for the D-backs to carry a pitcher who will value $34 million yearly. They want to trade him to anyone who will take that behemoth of a contract off their palms – even when it means choosing up a few of that wage.

It’s not even that Greinke wasn’t good whereas he was in Arizona. He was excellent, however his signing will stay a cautionary story for this group for years to come.

Dave Burns, co-host of Burns & Gambo: Trade him. Get off that contract. No cause to have a $100 million pitcher on a .500 workforce.

John Gambadoro, co-host of Burns & Gambo: Arizona ought to trade Zack Greinke, however it takes two to tango and there’s nothing on the desk proper now for a trade. The D-backs may have to possible wait out a few of free company and see what different trades for pitchers are made earlier than a staff decides to speak to Arizona about Greinke. In different phrases, what occurs to Dallas Keuchel, Nathan Eovaldi, J.A Happ and perhaps Madison Bumgarner will probably come earlier than a Greinke trade.

After the mud settles, no matter staff didn’t handle their beginning pitching the approach they needed to might come to the D-backs prepared to make a deal. There isn’t any cause to hold Greinke, and shedding payroll is a precedence this season. Arizona could have to eat a few of the contract and doubtless gained’t get again an entire lot prospect-wise, but when they will shed $60 million or so off the payroll of Greinke’s remaining $105 million, they will higher spend that cash elsewhere.

Jordan Byrd, producer of Burns & Gambo and host of Arizona Sports Saturday: The D-backs ought to trade Zack Greinke, however truly undertaking that is perhaps simpler stated than carried out. With a lot cash left on his contract, it’s going to take a prepared trade associate, plus the D-backs in all probability consuming a large chunk of Greinke’s remaining cash due. The D-backs are dropping Patrick Corbin, have traded Goldy and can doubtless lose A.J. Pollock to free company as nicely.

With these key piece gone the D-backs, at the second, will not be a playoff staff. May as properly begin the full rebuild and proceed the reconstruction with the items you will get from a Grienke trade. I’d fairly the group take a step again for a number of years to restock the roster than maintain on to Greinke and nonetheless not make the postseason with him on the group.

Matt Layman, ArizonaSports.com editor, reporter and social: I feel the query of whether or not you trade Greinke is dependent upon the marketplace for him. If you will get a strong return for him, go forward. However my worry is that due to the measurement of his contract, you’ll both: a) have to retain a lot of the cash that you simply may as nicely maintain him, or b) you’ll unload most of the cash however get little in return. If somebody is prepared to tackle vital wage and supply again a number of prospects/gamers which might be of any substantial worth, then I feel you progress him.

Kevin Zimmerman, ArizonaSports.com editor and reporter: The entrance workplace has continued to beat the “We’re still competitive” drum. We’ll see. In the event that they actually consider that and it’s true, they definitely have the capability to be affected person with Greinke. However yeah, if an inexpensive deal comes throughout Hazen’s desk, he in all probability wants to pull the set off on a deal. The D-backs gained’t get a lot for Greinke in any case.

Comply with @AZSports